Opinion

Heroes or Hostages?


by Ivana-Maria Carrioni-Burnett - published on 1 October 2020 80 -

Article first published by Human Rights at Sea (https://www.humanrightsatsea.org). All statements and opinions are from the author.

“Definitions"

‘Hero’: person who is admired for their courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities OR person greatly admired for their exceptional qualities or achievements

‘Hostage’: person seized or held for the fulfilment of a condition OR person who is illegally held prisoner until certain demands are met by others

Seafarer during COVID 19: person hailed a hero while treated as a hostage

It is the same story on nearly every ship I have boarded in the last few weeks. Professional introductions complete, radio call made, settling into the pilotage, looking to break the ice. The common thread: Tired. Fatigued. Tired of the hollow words of thanks. Tired of the empty promises. Tired of emails full of praise but empty of action. Tired of hoping for a crew change that never materialises.

I have read a copy of such an email to one crew. The sentiment is certainly touching. In reality, it is not enough.

The Day of the Seafarer was an international celebration held on the 25th June. Many organisations sought to use the day to pay tribute to the continued efforts of seafarers across the globe, maintaining vital supply routes during the COVID 19 epidemic, whilst seeking to raise awareness of their plight. At sea the smiles were scarce.

I spent the day seeking out webinars. Women Offshore hosted their first webinar with inspiring stories of success in the face of challenge. The conversation naturally kept sliding back towards COVID 19 and the fears it carried ashore. The International Maritime Organisation’s webinar was a mix of speeches calling for immediate action; lists of efforts made so far, with varying results; grave concerns for the future, particularly in the Philippines; and an effective Dutch solution which required extensive cross-border collaboration among a wide range of parties but did achieve some successful crew changes.

The Nautical Institute’s webinar was perhaps the most inspiring. It was noted that seafarers are proud, have been quietly getting on with their jobs and dealing with everything as it comes their way. Sacrifice was a key word that struck me but the sacrifice of seafarers is not fully understood by those outside of the maritime industry. Mariners are a crucial yet unseen part of our society.

Indeed, we are a proud bunch; we have every right to be! Maritime history has a rich tapestry dating back to The Flood. Storms come and go, both at sea and ashore. Seafarers are well versed in battening down the hatches, heaving-to and waiting out the weather. When the clouds clear, it is all hands on deck to ride the waves back to business.

As both a person of faith and a veteran of the British Armed Forces, the idea of sacrifice is not new to me. To every mariner, it is well understood that the job involves leaving friends, family and all the comforts of home. Serving military personnel know that there may come a time of no return, that the ultimate sacrifice may have to be made for a higher cause. Yet, the mariner leaves shore with the knowledge that there will be a return. Until COVID 19.

Distressingly, few land-lubbers understand the key role seafarers play in their lives. The distance an avocado travels to reach that smashed breakfast is referred to in terms of carbon footprints and air-miles, with no mention of refrigerated shipping containers or sea-miles and certainly no hint of the seafarer who has lovingly cradled it across oceans.

This July, Seafarers’ Awareness Week is being promoted by Seafarers UK and Maritime UK, coinciding with the Department for Transport’s Maritime Safety Week. Towards the end of the month, into August, is National Marine Week. The intent to raise awareness is certainly there. Yet, how many outside of the maritime industry are truly aware of our seafarers?

Summer 2020 must be a season of action. The UK Government is leading the charge to address crew change at an international ministerial level. In the meantime, we all have a responsibility to acknowledge the role seafarers play in our lives, sharing their stories and their plight. Seafarers are unable to raise their voices or strike for fear of ending up on a blacklist which means they struggle to find a job in the future. I know this happens because they have told me and it is widely reported despite being illegal. We must raise our voices for them: seafarers are keyworkers; seafarers are part of our society. Share their story.”

Editor's note:
Opinion pieces reflect the personal opinion of individual authors. They do not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a prevailing opinion in the respective editorial department. Opinion pieces might be deliberately formulated in a pronounced or even explicit tone and may contain biased arguments. They might be intended to polarise and stimulate discussion. In this, they deliberately differ from the factual articles you typically find on this platform, written to present facts and opinions in as balanced a manner as possible.
What's your opinion on this?
Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
Read more...

Opinion Empty Ships, Empty Seas

by Ivana-Maria Carrioni-Burnett - published on 21 September 2020

“The current plight many seafarers are facing, unable to crew change or return home, is being described by many voices within the maritime community as the next humanitarian crisis.”

0

Opinion UK Marine Pilot’s Perspective of Seafarer’s Challenges.

by Ivana-Maria Carrioni-Burnett - published on 24 August 2020

Port of London Authority marine Pilot, Ms. Ivana Carrioni-Burnett, provides a personal opinion and insight into her recent experiences in UK waters as a newly qualified Pilot in relation to her interactions with seafarers away from their families, including during the COVID-19 crisis.

0

Opinion Crew Voices: Fearful, Frustrated, Fatigued, Forgotten.

by Ivana-Maria Carrioni-Burnett - published on 2 September 2020

These are the feelings which have been voiced by the crews I have been in contact with during pilotage operations these last few weeks.

We have heard this said about many keyworkers in the UK over the last couple of months. First it was the NHS, then care workers and social workers, then bus drivers, train operators, lorry drivers and the supermarkets.

0

Video "Ship's Pilot" - A poem by Gaylen K. Bunker

published on 13 February 2020

A wonderful poem As read by the author From his books "Poems" Sometimes it is good just to stop and enjoy a poem. This poem "Ship's Pilot" is read by the author himself. A valuable piece about the nature of the pilot.

0

Video History: Pilot Cutter (1953)

published on 18 May 2020

Southampton, Hampshire. Various shots of Trinity House pilot cutter "Penda". M/S pilot's bridge. M/S as Second Officer Harry Goddard leaves the bridge and walks along the deck to his cabin. He takes his cap off, sits down at a table and looks at an album. C/U of his collection of matchbox labels. M/S Goddard sticking in more labels. C/U's Goddard and album. Various shots as he sticks in the labels. M/S of Pilot Knight and Captain Jolliff seated at desk. A waiter enters their cabin and...

0

Video Operation "Icebreaker" in Port of Quebec, Canada

published on 28 February 2020

Accelerated icebreaking operation of Pier 28 in the Estuary sector, involving Ocean Group's tugs.

0

Article Five questions for Esil Abibula, Head of Romanian Pilotage Department

published on 27 July 2023

In our section “Five questions for ..." Marine-Pilots.com introduces pilots and other market players to our readers in short interviews.

Today we have talked to Esil Abibula, Head of Romanian Pilotage Department.

3

Article Harbour Master Naresh Sewnath navigates his way to success

published on 13 October 2020

Two decades ago, candidates were selected for TNPA's accelerated training programme in Rotterdam, which aimed to train a new generation of ship pilots, managers and other maritime professionals.

0

Video GIDAS - GNSS Interference Detection & Analysis System

published on 29 April 2021

OHB Digital Solutions GmbH develops systems for monitoring the GNSS frequency bands as well as detection, classification and localization of intentional or unintentional interference sources. Many stakeholders and applications as well as critical infrastructure providers are relying on GNSS to provide their services. Since Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) are widely used in safety and value critical applications, GIDAS detects, classifies and localizes any GNSS interference...

0

Video Tug Girding

published on 30 November 2020

Between 2005 and 2018, the TSB received reports of 26 girding situations resulting in 21 capsizings. Girding occurs when a vessel is pulled broadside by a towline force and is unable to manoeuver out of this position. The TSB created this video to illustrate the factors leading to girding and the recovery methods.
The TSB would like to thank Ledcor Resources and Transportation Inc. for use of simulator training images in the girding video. We would also like to acknowledge the U.S....

1