Article

Pilot Secures Arrest of Chinese Cargo Ship Following Career-Ending Gangway Collapse


published on 15 March 2024 1570 -

Source: tradewinnews.com - Symbol photo by Antonio Alcaraz - www.harbourpilot.es

Fujian Shipping vessel ordered to stay put in Deendayal Port in rare case of a ship arrested against injury claim.

In a notable instance of legal action within the maritime industry, an Indian harbor pilot employed by the Deendayal Port Authority, Captain Shishir Nishikant Patange, has taken the extraordinary step of filing for an admiralty arrest. This action seeks compensation for injuries he alleges have prematurely ended his career in shipping.

Patange has successfully obtained an arrest warrant for the 44,700-dwt bulk carrier, Jin Hai Hua, owned by Fujian Shipping, built in 2012. The issuance of such a warrant over a personal injury claim is exceedingly rare.

The incident occurred when Patange was assigned to oversee the undocking of the Jin Hai Hua from the Deendayal Port Jetty on the afternoon of March 4. He reports that during his attempt to board the vessel via its gangway, the structure failed, overturning and collapsing, leading to his fall onto the wharf below.

This fall resulted in severe injuries to Patange's left wrist, including severe cuts, crushing, and fractures. Immediate medical attention was sought, and he was informed by healthcare professionals that he would suffer from permanent mobility loss in his left hand, despite surgical intervention.

This injury has led to Patange's assertion, through his legal representation to the Gujarat High Court in Ahmedabad, that he is now unable to perform his duties as a pilot effectively, thus signaling the end of his professional path in this field and a consequent permanent loss of income.

The claim against the Jin Hai Hua and its owners includes allegations of negligence in maintaining and monitoring the gangway's safety. Patange is seeking compensation amounting to INR 68 million (approximately $822,000) for the pain, suffering, and future income loss anticipated up until the age of 65. Additionally, he seeks coverage for legal expenses and interest.

Further, it was noted by Patange's legal team that he is still evaluating the full scope of the damages and retains the right to increase his compensation claim. They also highlighted that the Deendayal Port Authority has acknowledged responsibility for Patange's injuries incurred on duty, leading to their directive that the Jin Hai Hua remains within the port premises.

Concerns were raised by Patange regarding the potential for the port authority to allow the vessel to depart following the conclusion of their investigations, prompting the arrest application.

Shashank Agrawal, a maritime lawyer with SSA Legal, shared with TradeWinds that the scenario of arresting a vessel over a personal injury claim is highly unusual. The claimant is required to provide a written assurance to compensate for any court-awarded damages to the defendant vessel, should the arrest lead to any prejudice.

Agrawal suggested that Patange's decision to proceed with the arrest might have been influenced by the ship owner's residence in China, raising uncertainties about the vessel's return to Indian jurisdiction.

The arrest is expected to be revoked upon the deposition of a security by the ship’s protection and indemnity provider, identified by S&P Global data as the UK P&I Club.
What's your opinion on this?
Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
Read more...

Video Riding with the Savannah Pilots

published on 25 October 2020

Over the course of 4 days this August, I was afforded the opportunity and privilege of riding with the Savannah Bar Pilots for an article I was writing for a major maritime magazine. The pilots are given the responsibility of boarding a vessel in the Atlantic Ocean and safely navigating the vessel up the Tybee Road 9 (a name for the shipping lane that leads into the Savannah River), into the Savannah River, and into the Port of Savannah. The same is done in reverse when a ship is outbound...

1

Video How SHIP Navigate Through Ice (Part-1, Maneuvering)

published on 29 May 2021

This is part -1 (Maneuvering) In near future more parts will be added to the playslist. In person Appearing - Captain Thomas Madsen Chief officer,Aresh Daruwala Harbour Pilot, ST. Petersburg Company Credit - WWW.Maersk.com Location - Saint Petersburg, Russia Vessel - Venta Maersk Calender - (JANUARY - APRI), 2021 Music credit - Stock Music Filmora All video was shot on GoPro Hero 9 Edited through Adobe Light Room & Wondershare Filmora Subscribe...

0

Video Parking my Ship / Mombasa Kenya / Berthing Process

published on 6 August 2021

In this video we are trying to show how a ship enters into Mombasa port through a canal and the procedure of berthing.

0

Video Pilotage with PPU (Portable Pilot Unit) - Indonesia

published on 16 December 2021

assalamualaikum wr wb buat yang penasaran nih sama alat yang suka saya bawa kalo kerja, ini tampilannya ya teman2 terimakasih wassalamualaikum wr wb salma steady as she goes #berharap #pulih #harbourtug #pelabuhan

0

Article Factors affecting maritime pilots' health and well-being: a systematic review

published on 18 June 2021

Study from 2015: Psychological stressors, in addition to the physical demands associated with the role (e.g., reduced sleep, boarding, and departing vessels), may over time have a damaging effect on pilots' physical and mental health.

0

Opinion Hybrid War at Sea

by Frank Diegel - published on 25 March 2025

Electronic warfare in the Baltic Sea is escalating rapidly, with GPS and AIS disruptions posing growing risks to maritime navigation. Russia’s hybrid strategy is targeting both safety and stability in one of Europe’s most critical shipping regions. Pilots and crews now face a new reality: navigating under threat.

0

Video IMPA CHIRP Safety Campaign 2024 Video

published on 16 September 2024

IMPA and CHIRP Maritime have collaborated on a video to support the 2024 IMPA Safety Campaign and Survey which takes place 1 - 15 October 2024. More details can be found at www.impahq.org.

0

Video Pilot boat catches fire in Brazil

published on 17 January 2022

A pilot boat caught fire near the entrance of the Port of Recife, on Saturday morning (15 January). The fire would have started around 11h. In a note, the port authority explained that the two people who were in the pilot boat were rescued by another pilot boat "Serrambi".
The causes of the accident had not yet been identified, but would be investigated.

0

Video Montrose Port Authority Pilot Boat Arrival

published on 29 December 2022

Montrose Port Authority's new pilot boat was welcomed by water cannons as it arrived at its new home at the port of Montrose on Thursday 22nd December, making its journey from Ireland where the boat was constructed.
Read more about the pilot boat arrival on the Montrose Port Authority website: https://montroseport.co.uk/2022/12/23/pilot-boat-new/

0